CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil Review: The $6 Eyeliner That Does It All

Quick Overview

Why This Product Is Popular

Let me tell you why this Little pencil has sold millions of units over the years.

The eyeliner market is crowded. You have liquid liners that are impossible to control. You have gel liners that require a separate brush. You have wooden pencils that need constant sharpening and break constantly.

The CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus solves every single one of these problems.

Here are five reasons this eyeliner is a cult favorite.

1. No Sharpening. Ever.

This is the #1 reason people buy this eyeliner. The specially designed tip self-sharpens as you use it. You never need a separate sharpener. You never have a dull tip. You never break the tip off while sharpening. You just twist (or use it) and the tip stays perfect. It is the most convenient eyeliner on the market.

2. The Built-In Smudger Tip

Want a sharp, clean line? Use the tip as is. Want a smoky, diffused look? Flip the pencil around and use the soft smudger tip on the other end. One pencil gives you two completely different looks. No need for a separate smudging brush or your pinky finger.

3. Glides On Smoothly (No Tugging)

Have you ever used an eyeliner that drags and tugs at your delicate eye area? It hurts. It creates jagged lines. It ages your Skin. The CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus glides on like Butter. The formula is creamy enough to apply smoothly but firm enough to Stay put.

4. The Perfect Shade Range

This Review features Espresso—a versatile, rich brown. Brown eyeliner is having a moment. It is softer than black. It looks Natural. It works for daytime, Work, and casual looks. But CoverGirl also offers Charcoal (soft grey-black), Midnight Blue (adds a pop of color), and classic Black. Something for everyone.

5. Cruelty-Free & Affordable

CoverGirl is Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty-Free International. That means no animal testing at any stage of production. And at $5.97, this is one of the most affordable cruelty-free eyeliners on the market. You do not have to choose between your Budget and your values.

When 26,782 people give a product 4.4 stars, and it holds an Amazon's Choice badge, you know you have found a winner.

Key Features (Deep Dive)

Let me break down exactly why this eyeliner performs so well.

1. Self-Sharpening Tip (No Sharpener Needed)

• What it is: A specially engineered tip that maintains its point as you use it.

• How it works: The pencil is designed so that the tip wears down evenly, always exposing fresh product in a pointed shape.

• The benefit to you: You never have to search for a sharpener. You never break the tip. You never waste product shaving down a wooden pencil. Just use it. Perfect tip every time.

2. Built-In Soft Smudging Tip

• What it is: A soft foam or sponge tip on the opposite end of the pencil.

• How it works: After applying the eyeliner, flip the pencil and use the smudger to soften and diffuse the line.

• The benefit to you: One pencil gives you two looks. A sharp, clean line for a classic look. A soft, smoky line for a sultry evening look. No extra tools needed.

3. Long-Lasting Formula

• What it is: A wax-based formula that adheres to the skin and resists fading.

• How it works: The formula contains ingredients that grip the skin without smearing or transferring throughout the day.

• The benefit to you: Your eyeliner stays put from morning until night. No raccoon eyes. No mid-day touch-ups.

4. Smooth, Creamy Application

• What it is: A formula that balances creaminess and firmness perfectly.

• How it works: Too soft and the liner smears everywhere. Too hard and it tugs and hurts. CoverGirl found the sweet spot.

• The benefit to you: Application is effortless. The pencil glides across your lash line without pulling or skipping. It feels comfortable, not painful.

5. Versatile Shade: Espresso (Rich Brown)

• What it is: A deep, warm brown that is softer than black.

• How it works: Brown eyeliner defines your eyes without the harshness of black. It looks natural and complements every eye color.

• The benefit to you: You can wear this eyeliner every single day. It works for work, school, errands, and evenings. It makes blue eyes pop, green eyes Glow, and brown eyes look deeper.

6. Leaping Bunny Certified Cruelty-Free

• What it means: CoverGirl has been certified by Cruelty-Free International, the gold standard for animal testing-free products.

• How it works: Independent audits verify that no animal testing occurs at any stage of production.

• The benefit to you: You can feel good about what you are putting on your Face. No guilt. No compromise.

Benefits (How It Improves Your Life)

• Get ready faster: No sharpening. No searching for tools. No frustration. Just grab, apply, and go. You save 2-3 minutes every morning.

• One pencil, two looks: Sharp line for work. Smoky line for dinner. You do not need to carry two eyeliners or a separate brush.

• No more raccoon eyes: The long-lasting formula stays where you put it. No smudging down your face by 2 PM.

• Gentle on your eye area: The smooth-glide formula does not tug or pull. No premature wrinkles from dragging a hard pencil across your skin.

• Perfect for tightlining: The fine, self-sharpening tip is ideal for getting between your lashes. Tightlining makes your lashes look fuller without obvious eyeliner.

• Cruelty-free peace of mind: You are supporting a brand that does not test on animals. Leaping Bunny certification is the real deal.

• Affordable enough to buy multiple shades: At $5.97, you can buy Espresso for daily wear, Charcoal for evenings, and Midnight Blue for fun. Your entire eyeliner collection costs less than one prestige pencil.

• Travel-friendly: No sharpener needed. No fragile wooden pencil that can break. Just toss it in your bag and go.

Who Should Buy This?

✅ Buy this if:

• You are tired of sharpening eyeliner pencils.

• You want a soft, natural brown eyeliner (Espresso) for daily wear.

• You want the option to create both sharp lines AND smoky looks.

• You have sensitive eyes and need a smooth-glide formula.

• You are looking for an affordable, cruelty-free eyeliner.

• You want to try tightlining (getting liner between your lashes).

• You need a reliable backup eyeliner for your purse or travel bag.

• You love drugstore makeup that performs like high-end.

❌ Do not buy this if:

• You want a waterproof formula (this is long-lasting but not waterproof).

• You need an ultra-precise liquid liner wing (this is a pencil).

• You prefer gel liner in a pot (different application style).

• You want a very bold, dramatic black line (try the Black shade instead of Espresso).

Honest Downsides (For Trust)

"I am an affiliate. Here is what 26,782 real buyers wish was Better."

1. Not waterproof: This eyeliner is long-lasting and smudge-resistant, but it is not waterproof. If you have watery eyes, live in a humid climate, or cry easily (no judgment), this may not last all day. For truly waterproof, try a liquid liner or gel.

2. The smudger tip can get dirty: Over time, the foam smudger tip collects product and can look messy. Wipe it with a tissue after each use. Replace the pencil when the smudger gets too dirty.

3. Espresso is a warm brown, not cool: If you have very cool undertones or prefer an ashier brown, Espresso may look too warm. Try Charcoal (soft grey-black) instead for a cooler neutral.

4. The pencil is tiny (0.01 oz): At this size, the pencil is small. It will last 2-3 months with daily use, but do not expect it to last a year. The price ($5.97) reflects the size.

5. International shipping costs are high ($17.84 to Saudi Arabia): For customers outside the US, shipping can cost three times the product itself. Use the affiliate link provided—it is for the US Amazon store. International buyers can use Amazon Currency Converter at checkout. Consider buying a 2-pack to spread the shipping cost.

Comparison: CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus vs. Other Eyeliners

Price & Value

• Current Price: $5.97

• Cost per use (est.): Approximately $0.06 (based on 100 uses)

• Estimated longevity: 2-3 months of daily use

• 2-pack available: Yes (better value for international shipping)

Is it Worth it?

Let me be direct.

A single coffee from Starbucks costs $5-7. That is gone in 15 minutes.

This eyeliner costs $5.97 and will last you 2-3 months of daily use. That is $0.06 per day for perfectly defined eyes, no sharpening, and built-in smudging.

You spend more on a single tube of lip Balm. You spend more on a pack of makeup wipes. This is one of the best values in all of drugstore makeup.

Real User Experience (Simulated Feedback from 26,782 Reviews)

"After using CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus for 3 months…"

"I have been using this eyeliner for YEARS. I try other brands, but I always come back. The fact that I never have to sharpen it is a lifesaver. Espresso is the perfect brown—not too dark, not too light. My everyday holy grail." – Jessica T.

"I have unsteady hands. Liquid liner is impossible for me. This pencil is so forgiving. I can draw a line, smudge it slightly if I mess up, and it looks intentional. The smudger tip is genius." – Amanda S.

"I Bought Espresso because black eyeliner looks too harsh on my fair skin. This brown is perfect. It defines my eyes without looking like I am wearing a ton of makeup. I feel more confident at work." – Emily R.

"Honest review: It is not waterproof. I cried at a wedding and it ran. But for everyday use, it stays put all day. Just do not wear it to funerals or sad movies." – Marcus L.

"I switched to cruelty-free makeup and was worried about finding good drugstore options. This eyeliner is Leaping Bunny certified AND cheap. Win-win. The self-sharpening tip is a bonus." – Priya K.

How to Use

Classic Sharp Line (Clean, Defined Look)

Step 1: Start with clean, dry eyelids.

Step 2: Gently pull your eyelid taut (not too tight).

Step 3: Starting at the inner corner, draw small dots or dashes along your upper lash line.

Step 4: Connect the dots into a smooth, continuous line.

Step 5: For a wing, extend the line slightly past the outer corner.

Step 6: Do not use the smudger. Leave the line sharp.

Smoky, Diffused Line (Soft, Sultry Look)

Step 1: Apply the eyeliner as described above.

Step 2: Do not let it dry completely.

Step 3: Flip the pencil and use the soft smudger tip.

Step 4: Gently smudge the line back and forth to soften the edges.

Step 5: For extra smokiness, apply a second layer and smudge again.

Step 6: Apply to your lower lash line (outer half only) and smudge.

Tightlining (Invisible Lash Enhancement)

Step 1: Tilt your head back and look down into a mirror.

Step 2: Gently lift your upper eyelid to expose the waterline.

Step 3: Using the fine tip, dot the liner between your upper lashes.

Step 4: Do not line the waterline itself (can irritate eyes). Just between the lashes.

Step 5: Your lashes will look instantly fuller and thicker.

Lower Lash Line Application

Step 1: Apply liner to your upper lash line first.

Step 2: For the lower lash line, apply only to the outer half or outer third.

Step 3: Smudge immediately for a softer look.

Step 4: Avoid lining the entire lower waterline (can make eyes look smaller).

Pro Tips (For Maximum Results)

1. Warm the pencil slightly before use: If the formula feels too hard, roll the pencil between your hands for 5 seconds. The warmth softens the product for an Even smoother glide.

2. Set with matching eyeshadow: For all-day wear, apply the eyeliner, then dust a matching brown eyeshadow over it. This locks the liner in place and prevents smudging.

3. Use the smudger for a gradient effect: Apply a thicker line, smudge it out, then apply another thin line on top without smudging. You get a sharp inner edge and a smoky outer edge.

4. Create a wing using tape: Place a small piece of scotch tape at an angle from your outer corner. Draw your wing along the tape edge. Remove the tape. Perfect wing every time.

5. Store the pencil tip-up: When not in use, store the pencil with the tip pointing up. This prevents the tip from getting squished or flattened.

6. Clean the smudger tip weekly: Dip the smudger tip in a little micellar water or alcohol. Wipe on a tissue. Let dry. The smudger will work like new.

7. Buy a 2-pack for travel: The pencil is small and Easy to lose. Buy a 2-pack and keep one in your makeup bag and one in your travel kit. You will never be without it.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. Is the CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus eyeliner waterproof?

No, it is long-lasting but not waterproof. The formula resists smudging and fading throughout the day, but it is not designed to withstand water, tears, or humidity. If you need a waterproof eyeliner for swimming, crying, or humid climates, try a liquid waterproof liner or a gel liner.

2. Does it actually self-sharpen? How does that work?

Yes, it really does. The pencil is designed with a special mechanism that exposes fresh product in a pointed shape as you use it. You never need a separate sharpener. The tip stays consistently fine and precise. It is one of the best features of this pencil.

3. Is Espresso a warm or cool brown?

Espresso is a warm, rich brown. It has reddish-brown undertones. It is beautiful on warm and neutral skin tones. If you have very cool undertones or prefer an ashier, grey-brown, try the Charcoal shade (soft grey-black) instead.

4. Is this eyeliner good for sensitive eyes?

Yes, for most people. The formula is smooth and does not tug or drag. Many users with sensitive eyes report no irritation. However, everyone's eyes are different. If you have known allergies, patch test on your hand first. Avoid applying to the waterline if you are prone to styes or irritation.

5. Is CoverGirl actually cruelty-free?

Yes. CoverGirl is Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty-Free International. This is the gold standard for cruelty-free certification. It means no animal testing occurs at any stage of production, from ingredients to finished product. CoverGirl is also sold in China (where testing was historically required), but they have worked with regulators to certify their products without animal testing.

6. How long does one pencil last?

2-3 months with daily use. The pencil contains 0.01 oz of product. With daily application (both upper lash lines), you should get 60-90 uses. The self-sharpening mechanism ensures no product is wasted, unlike wooden pencils where you sharpen away a lot of product.

7. Why is shipping to Saudi Arabia $17.84 for a $5.97 product?

International shipping is expensive because of weight, dimensions, and air freight costs. The pencil is tiny, but the packaging plus international transport adds up. Pro tips:

• Buy a 2-pack or multi-pack to spread the shipping cost.

• Add other small CoverGirl products to your order.

• Use the Amazon Currency Converter at checkout to pay in your local currency.

8. Can I use this on my waterline (tightline)?

Yes, with caution. The formula is safe for the waterline for most people. However, if you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, be careful. The Espresso shade is great for tightlining because it defines the eyes without looking harsh. If you experience any irritation, discontinue use on the waterline.

9. What is the difference between Espresso and the Black shade?

If you can only buy one, start with Espresso. It is more versatile for daily wear.

10. Is this good for beginners?

Yes, absolutely. This is one of the best eyeliners for beginners. The self-sharpening tip means you always have a precise point. The smooth formula is forgiving. The built-in smudger can fix mistakes instantly. And the Espresso shade is softer and more forgiving than black. This is the perfect "first eyeliner" for someone learning makeup.

SEO Keywords

• CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus eyeliner review

• Best brown eyeliner pencil for daily wear

• Self sharpening eyeliner no sharpener needed

• Espresso eyeliner for brown eyes

• Cruelty free drugstore eyeliner

• CoverGirl eyeliner with smudger tip

• Long lasting eyeliner pencil for waterline

• Best eyeliner for tightlining

• CoverGirl vs NYX eyeliner comparison

• Brown eyeliner for fair skin

• Smoky eye pencil with built in smudger

• Affordable everyday eyeliner

• Leaping Bunny certified makeup

• CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Espresso shade

• Best eyeliner for beginners

Final Verdict

Here is the truth.

Eyeliner should not be complicated. It should not require a specialty sharpener. It should not tug at your delicate eye skin. It should not cost a fortune.

The CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil in Espresso is simple. It is effective. It is convenient.

No sharpening. Built-in smudger. Smooth-glide formula. Long-lasting wear. Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free. And just $5.97.

Over 26,000 people gave it 4.4 stars. 3,000+ people bought it in the past month. It is an Amazon's Choice product.

If you want a soft, natural, everyday brown eyeliner that makes getting ready faster and easier, buy this pencil. One swipe. Perfect eyes. No frustration.

✅ Check on Amazon

Meta Data

• Meta Title: CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Review: Espresso Brown, No Sharpening Needed

• Meta Description: 26,782+ reviews! Self-sharpening brown eyeliner with built-in smudger. Long-lasting, cruelty-free, Leaping Bunny certified. Only $5.97. Check price on Amazon.

• Slug: covergirl-perfect-point-plus-eyeliner-espresso-review

•